|
|
This is Q and Ans
HinduOfUniverse
Hinduism - Frequently
asked questions
Why there are so many gods in Hinduism ?
Generally Hindus believe in one Supreme God. But there are many
gods who are praised in the religion. These gods are actually the life
supporting powers. For example Sun (Surya), Water (Varuna), and
Air (Vayu) without which the life cannot exist. In Hinduism these
elements which make the life possible are praised along with the Very Essential
God. This gives the feeling that Hindus believe in many gods. At the end God is
still but in differenr names as Vishnu, Ram or Krishna.
- 2.1. Is Hinduism polytheistic
(accepts many gods)?
Is Hinduism pantheistic
(involves worshipping nature - trees, hills, etc)?
Why do Hindus worship stones ? Why do Hindu
Gods have fancy forms like elephant faced, monkey faced, with six faces, with
four hands, etc ?
- 2.2. Who is the founder of Hinduism
?
Which is the book of Hinduism ?
- 2.3. Who is a Hindu ?
Can I get converted into Hinduism ?
- 2.4. Should I know Sanskrit to be a
Hindu ?
- 2.5.Does Hinduism consider monastic
life better ?
- 2.6.Does Hinduism consider
vegetarianism better ?
- 2.7.What does Hinduism say about
polygamy, homosexuality, etc ?
- 2.8.What is the Hindu concept
of life after death ?
What is the Hindu
concept of Heaven and Hell ?
- 2.9.Is there the concept similar to Satan
in Hinduism ?
- 2.10.Is there a concept of sin in Hinduism
?
- 2.11.Do all Hindu saints perform
miracles ?
- 2.12.Does astrology come under
Hinduism ?
- 2.13.There are many
contradictions in Hinduism. For example, Rama is hailed for monogamy, but
Krishna has many wives.
- 2.14.What is the Hindu concept of
creation ?
What is the Hindu concept of destruction ?
- 2.15.What does Hinduism say about
conversion ?
- 2.16.What does Hinduism say about
science ?
- 2.17.What is Hinduism's stand on human
cloning ?
- 2.18.What is Hinduism's stand on
euthanasia (assisted suicide) ?
- 2.19.What is Hinduism's stand on
abortion and contraception ?
- 2.20.How do Hindus pray ? What is the
Hindu prayer ?
- 2.21.Do Hindus say any prayer before
eating food ?
Fundamental Questions:
1.1. What is Hinduism ?
When was Hinduism founded ?
The name 'Hinduism' is
of a much recent origin, coined by the Greeks and Arabians to refer to the
religion of the people living around and to the East of the river Indus. The
earliest records of this religion are in the Rig Veda, the oldest known human
literature. Some portions of the Rig Veda have been dated to before 6000 BC.
This implies that the religion was in vogue atleast a few centuries earlier than
that. Hinduism has been gaining increasing popularity due to its high
philosophy, broad outlook and non-dogmatic approach. Hinduism is different from
many other religions in that it does not have a founder and does not claim
exclusivity. It explicitly accepts all religions as valid.
1.2. How has Hinduism
survived for so long ? Is the Hinduism practised today the same as that
practiced a few millenia ago ?
Hinduism has stood
the test of time much more effectively than any other religion of the world.
This is mainly because of its clear separation of the essentials from the
non-essentials. Every religion has a few principles, which are independant of
the cultural context of the followers, and a few practices which need to vary
with time, place and cultural background. Hinduism has clearly separated these
two right since its known history. The principles are presented in texts
classified as 'Sruthis', which primarily comprise the part of the Vedas called
Upanisads. The changable texts are classified as 'Smritis', which include
various texts on etiquette, moral and ethical codes of conduct, law and justice.
The former form the universal principles and the latter form their
culture-dependant implementation. The essential principles of Hinduism are the
same as they were concieved of by the sages who lived during the Vedic period.
Even the Vedas have come down to the present day unaltered. The Vedas are being
chanted even today with the same melody and rhythm as they were chanted during
the Vedic age. The social customs and values have changed to cater to the needs
and to utilize the means of changing times and culture, without altering the
basic principles and goals.
1.3. Why is there so much
confusion about Hinduism ? I see Hinduism as a mass of conflicting ideas.
Due to the enormous time period through which Hinduism has
been practised, it has passed through a huge spectrum of cultural environments.
Due to this, the non-essential portion of Hinduism has passed through so much
changes in various places during various times. This has resulted in a situation
where even people who have born and grown in Hinduism face a lot of difficulty
in understanding Hinduism. Many see Hinduism as a huge mass of conflicting
ideas. This is mainly due to two interrelated reasons.
- Not distinguishing between the essentials and the
non-essentials.
- Trying to apply the culture-dependant non-essential
concepts out of context.
This gives rise to a plethora of questions in the
minds of almost anyone who come in touch with Hinduism. This FAQ is an attempt
to answer a few of these questions.
1.4. What are the basic principles
of Hinduism ?
The basic principles of Hinduism are
in the Upanisads. They have been collected, organized and explained in various
other texts, but the root source are the Upanisads. Hinduism has three basic
principles.
- It is God who has become this Universe and everything
in it.
Whatever is seen, dreamed or imagined are nothing but manifestations of God.
God is beyond space, time, causation and all distinctions like gender, race,
species, living/non-living and form/formless. Since He is beyond space, He is
omnipresent. Since He is beyond time, He is eternal. Since He is beyond the
concept of form, He is with form, without form, both and neither. Every form is
His and yet He is formless and beyond the concept of form. Similarly with all
attributes concievable by the mind.
- The aim of life is to 'know' God.
God cannot
be 'known' in the usual sense of the word. God is the Knower of everything. We
call it 'realizing' God. This is beyond the mind. It is a direct experience of
God. This is the ultimate goal of life. Till we reach this goal, we will have to
live again and again. Till we reach this goal, we have to undergo birth, death
and again birth and so on. Everytime we are born, we continue our journey
towards the goal from where we left. So nothing is lost by death on this
journey. When the goal is reached, there is no need for anymore death or birth.
The person is said to have attained Immortality. Actually the person goes beyond
all limitations. Even the basic limitations imposed by the concept of
individuality and personality vanish. There are intermediate milestones and
targets set by Hinduism. They are Dharma - righteousness, Artha - wealth
acquired by righteous means and Kama - quenching of desires within the limits of
Dharma and Artha. As there is a scope for lot of misconception about these
intermediate targets, there are several texts explaining them. These are
intermediate targets and not ends. The ultimate aim is Moksha - freedom from
limitations by God realization. Dharma, Artha and Kama should be stepping stones
and thus means to the end, which is Moksha. But this does not mean that Artha
and Kama are forbidden by Hinduism. According to Hinduism, if people pursue and
enjoy Artha and Kama within the boundaries of Dharma, they will naturally
develop the maturity to enquire and aspire after Moksha in due course of time.
- As many people, so many ways to God.
Every
religion is a way to God. No way to God is superior to the other. However,
depending on the mental temperament and cultural background of a person, one way
might be better suited to him than another. This is difference arises due to the
difference in the temperament of the person and cannot be used to judge the
general efficacy of a path. "All paths are true. Your path for you. My path for
me." This is the principle of Hinduism.
Everything else is secondary and should not violate these three basic
principles.
Back to Top
Beginner Level Questions:
2.1. Is Hinduism
polytheistic (accepts many gods)? Is Hinduism pantheistic (involves
worshipping nature - trees, hills, etc)? Why do Hindus worship stones ?
Why do Hindu Gods have fancy forms like elephant faced, monkey faced, with six
faces, with four hands, etc ?
Hinduism says that
there is one God. Just as a man is called "father" by this son, "husband" by his
wife, "son" by this father, and so on, God is called by various names and
worshipped in various forms depending on the mood and approach of the devotee.
When God is worshipped to remove hurdles, He is worshipped as "Ganesha". When
God is worshipped to bless with good understanding of art and science, He is
worshipped as "Saraswathi", and so on. Similarly, when a devotee wants to
worship God as mother, he may worship as "Kali". When a devotee wants to worship
God as a child, he may worship as "Krishna". If a devotee wants to worship God
as the formless, attributeless, transcedent being, he may worship as "Brahman".
These are all to suit the various temperaments of the devotees. By all these
various forms and names, the devotee very well knows that He is worshipping God
only. So Hinduism is monotheistic.
Hinduism also accepts that all religions talk about the
one God. It does not have concepts like the god of the Egyptians and the god of
the Jews, which basically implies that there are many gods. Hinduism says that
the god of the Hindus, Egyptians, Jews, Christians, Muslims, Zorastrians,
Aztecs, Mayans, Maoris, etc are all the same God. Hinduism says that all are
worshipping the same God in different ways. Again, one way is not better than
the other way. All ways to worship God are accepted by God if performed with
faith and devotion.
In fact, it goes one step ahead than other religions. Not
only that it says there is only one God; it says that everything in this
universe are manifestations of God. In Hinduism, there is no the concept of
"creation" in the literal sense of the word. It is God who becomes or manifests
as the universe. The universe is not different from God. Everything is God. So,
the devotee can take anything which appeals to him as a form of God, and worship
Him. The omniscient God knows that the devotee is worshipping Him. The exact
name and form do not matter. The attitude and sincerity is what matters.
Similarly a Hindu does not worship a tree or a hill just
because it is a tree or a hill. The tree or hill is considered a symbol of God
and it is the transcendent God who is worshipped through the natural objects. It
is the Creator who is worshipped through the creation. So Hinduism is not
pantheistic.
An abstract idea is expressed in a concrete form for the
mind to grasp easily. For example, to depict the idea that God protects the
devotee from the forces of evil, God is depicted with various weapons. Every
small aspect of the forms of various Hindu Gods and Goddesses have a meaning
behind them. There is a technical convention of symbology followed. For example,
a bow indicated the mind; arrows indicate the senses; noose indicates death;
drum indicates time; rosary indicates austerity. The symbology is very elaborate
and quite context independant. The picture with all this symbology indicate the
personality attributed for the particular form of God. If the devotee also has
similar aspirations, he chooses the form of God for his worship. As he thinks
about the various aspects in the form, he thinks of the aspect of personality
the symbol indicates. This way the form is an excellent aid to think of God with
certain attributes. For a person who does not know the language of this
symbology, it is a fancy picture. But for a person who understands, it is an
excellent aid for worship. Also, there is a lot of myths, legends and nice
stories associated with every form of God. This allows the devotee to get a very
good hold on to the personality and also have a personal psychological
relationship with the personality. This offers great stability to the
personality of the devotee. The characters which he is aspiring for are deeply
engraved in his mind and provide a strong foothold. It is common in the
picturization to use various human, animal and even mixed forms. All these have
meanings. Any book on the particular aspect of God will give you the exact
symbology.
To give further aid to the devotee, even historical
characters like Rama, Krishna and various people who lived exemplary lives are
given a form with a lot of symbols added. A good example is Hanuman, the
monkey-faced. He was a highly self-controlled, learned, wise and loyal devotee
of Rama. His devotion to Rama was outstanding. He was very strong in all aspects
- physical, mental, moral, emotional andd intellectual. He is worshipped by
devotees to grant them his qualities. The story of Rama has accounts of numerous
incidents where his hero has showed his covetable qualities. These stories
create a vivid picture in the mind of the devotees and encourages them to
develop the same qualities.
The ancient Hindus were highly advanced in the science of
psychology. There are numerous treatises on this subject. Different forms are
found to create different psychological effects. It is by considering this that
the various forms are given to various aspects of God. For example, the forms of
elephant and mouse seem to arouse the security consciousness in the mind of man.
These are used in the form of Ganesha. Thus the form of Ganesha will increase
the alerness of the mind. So a worship of Ganesha is advocated before starting
anything new. These symbols come from the technical expertise of the ancient
Hindus in this field.
2.2. Who is the founder of
Hinduism ? Which is the book of Hinduism ?
Hinduism does not have a founder. It has been there from prehistoric times. It
is based on the spiritual concepts discovered by numerous people. These concepts
are impersonal like other concepts in science. These concepts have been
validated by innumerable people. Hinduism invites everyone, irrespective of the
cultural background, to validate the truth of the spiritual concepts for
themselves.
There is no single book for Hinduism. If you are looking
for a source where all the principles are given, then there are three texts.
They are called "Prasthana Traya" - the principal three. They all present the
same truth.
The first is the Upanisads. These are parts of the
Vedas. There are innumerable Upanisads. Ten of them were chosen by Sri Sankara,
a great saint and philosopher, as to contain the ideas in all the Upanisads put
together. This forms the first principal text. These are unadultered, raw,
first-hand observations of spiritual phenomenon. They do not try to propose a
model to fit the observations. The observers have not imposed their ideas or
even tried to classify the observations.
The second is the Brahma Sutras. This was authored
by Veda Vyasa, who masterminded the current organization of the Vedas and the
same person who authored other great works like Mahabharata and Bhagavata.
Brahma Sutras present the concept in the Upanishads in a logical and highly
technical manner. It is a scholarly work which establishes the concepts in the
Upanishads on a strong logical foundation.
The third is the Bhagavad Gita. This is a record of
the conversation between Sri Krishna and Arjuna. This text talks about the
practical application of the concepts in the Upanisads to everyday life.
Thus these three texts present the Hindu philosophy and
religion in a scientific and practical manner as - observation, modelling and
application.
2.3. Who is a Hindu ? Can I
get converted into Hinduism ?
A Hindu is one who
believes in the basic principles of Hinduism and applies them to everyday life.
The principles are explained above. To repeat, basically they are
- There is one God, who has become everything in this
universe. This implies that everyone and everything has to be considered with
due regard. This talks about the basic unity of the whole universe. This implies
that one had to strive for the welfare of the whole. There is no place for
selfishness and narrowness.
- The aim of life is to realize God. There is no room for a
desultory living. Life has a great divine purpose. It is to overcome all
limitations by realizing the divinity within.
- Every path to God is true. Everyone has to chose a path
to God according to one's own temperament. There is no conflict between various
religions.
If you follow these principles, you are a Hindu. It
does not matter whether you worship Krishna or Christ or Allah. If you believe
in the inherent equality and divinity of the universe, strive to realize the
divinity in yourself and accept the plurality of religion, you are a Hindu.
As Hinduism considers all religions as equally valid paths
to God, there is no concept of conversion. Hinduism is a sort of meta-religion.
It encompasses the basic principles of religion. It helps you to fix your
religious goal, choose any religion of your choice and encourages you to follow
the religion with all sincerity. Understand the aim of religion. Weigh the pros
and cons of various ways of worship available in world. Choose one of your
liking and follow it with full zeal. In all probability, you are already
worshipping God in your favorite way. Hinduism helps you to follow you religion
more knowingly, with a clearer understanding of the goal and with more zeal.
2.4. Should I know Sanskrit to be a
Hindu ?
No. Almost all the scriptures and
traditional prayers are in Sanskrit. So if you want to go to the source, you
need to know Sanskrit. But to follow the religion, you need not know Sanskrit.
There are good translations of almost all the major texts in several other
languages, from which you can derive benefit. What is important is to understand
and follow the principles. But, if you want to understand and appreciate Indian
culture, a knowledge of Sanskrit and other Indian languages is necessary. Much
of the culture is embedded in the word formations and connotations. Also, you
cannot have a direct first-hand experience of the Indian culture without the
knowledge of the language in which the culture is implemented.
2.5. Does Hinduism consider monastic
life better ?
No. During the course of Indian
history, late Buddhism brought in this idea, which led to the downfall of India.
The genius of Sri Sankara converted this downfall into the "downfall of Buddhism
in India" and put the society back onto the progressive track. Hinduism
considers the householders and monastics as two wings of the bird called
society. Whether to chose the life of a householder or a monastic depends on the
individual temperament. The aim of life - God realization - can be achieved in
both the ways of life. Just as there are various duties to various people in the
society, the monastics also have their role and duties. The monks are the
repositories of religious knowledge and are teachers of religious life. The
respect given to their position is a psychological necessity to derive maximum
benefit from their knowledge. Also, they are supposed to expressedly and
explicitly follow the virtues like service, sacrifice and nobility which the
householders are supposed to implicitly follow. This way they are role models
for the rest of the society. But this does not mean that the monatic way of life
is better than the householders. The same virtues are expected in both.
2.6.Does Hinduism consider
vegetarianism better ?
No. The concept of
vegetarianism is recent (less than 2000 years old). The historical accounts
recorded in the Ramayana, Mahabharata and the Puranas depict people as
non-vegetarian. Hinduism accepts the law of nature that one life is the food for
another. However, Hinduism accepts that just as the mind affects the body (you
want to lift your hand and your body does it), the body also affects the mind.
The food eaten affects the organization and type of thoughts. For example,
eating stolen food has been found to make the mind morally weak. Similarly,
different types of food cause different effects in the mind. Non-vegetarian diet
has been found to cause a condition called "rajotamas" - a mixture of delusion
and hyperactivity. This is an undesirable condition for aspirants of God. A
vegetarian diet aids control of the mind and religious study. For this reason,
modern Hinduism advises a vegetarian diet to most spiritual aspirants.
2.7.What does Hinduism say about
polygamy, homosexuality, etc ?
The aim of life
according to Hinduism is God realization. Social issues like polygamy are
outside the jurisdiction of religion. If the question is "What does Hinduism say
about lust?", then there is a prompt and vehement reply that "Lust has to be
overcome." Social rules will change with time and place. Some societies consider
polygamy as normal. There are Hindu societies in North Eastern India, which
consider polyandry as normal and anyone opposing it as "selfish". Nevertheless,
they are good Hindu societies. Majority of today's Indian society is monogamous.
A few years before polygamy was accepted. It may again get accepted after a few
centuries. Hinduism is not bothered about these. It has higher goals for life.
2.8.What is the Hindu
concept of life after death ? What is the Hindu concept of Heaven and Hell ?
Hinduism believes in the law of cause and effect applied to
all spheres of phenomenal existence. Since different people are born to
different people in different environments (which is an observed effect), a
previous cause has to be assumed. The only logical explanation possible is a
previous life very similar to this. And by the same argument, since different
people are involved in different thoughts and activities till death, the effects
of these must occur in an after-life very similar to this. Hinduism says that
everyone is responsible for his life. There are no extraneous causes for one's
condition in life. If a person is facing hardship in life it has to be due to
his earlier thoughts and actions in this or previous life.
2.9.Is there the concept similar to
Satan in Hinduism ?
Hinduism does not have a
concept similar to Satan. Hinduism says that all that happens are due to the
power and will of God. Whatever happens is neither good nor bad. It is human
beings who attribute those ideas to events. We call something which we think
will cause intended effects, within the purview of our understanding, as good.
All understanding is limited and hence the very concept of good and evil is
relative and depends on time, place and people involved.
2.10.Is there a concept of sin in
Hinduism ?
No. Hinduism says that one has to reap
what he sows - good or bad. If a person makes mistakes, he will have to face the
consequences. If a person does good, he will enjoy its fruits. Hinduism opens
the door fully for a person to form his own life and future. No one is eternally
glorified or eternally doomed. It accepts that people make mistakes whose
logical effects have to be faced, its lessons need to be learnt, and life has to
continue with more knowledge and understanding.
2.11.Do all Hindu saints perform
miracles ?
No. Miracles are considered mere
dynamics of Nature which are not understood fully by the observer. Miracles are
nothing different from regular events. If something is not expected, it is a
miracle. They are not worth to be sought after. The goal of Hinduism is to
realize God. Miracles are considered objectionable hinderances towards that
goal. No teacher of Hinduism advises his disciples to attain the power to do
miracles. Seeking after miracles is considered a sign of spiritual weakness.
2.12.Does astrology come under
Hinduism ?
No. Astrology is just another science
like agriculture or metallurgy. It is well developed in India, just like
religion and philosophy. The theory behind astrology is based on the Indian view
that everything in this universe originate from one source. So by a reasonable
understanding of the dynamics in one part of the universe, one can expect a
particular pattern of events in another part of the universe. Beyond that there
is no relationship.
2.13.There are many
contradictions in Hinduism. For example, Rama is hailed for monogamy, but
Krishna has many wives.
This again is the result
of applying today's social norms like monogamy to people who lived a few
thousand years back. Rama is hailed for monogamy today. But during his time,
polygamy was not considered objectionable.
2.14.What is the Hindu concept of
creation ?
Hinduism considers that the world is a
manifestation of God. There is no concept of Creation and a Creator. The world
came from God, exists in God and will return back to God, just like waves arise
from the ocean, exist in the ocean and subside back into the ocean. And this
happens in cycles, again and again.
As there is no concept of creation in the literal sense,
there can be no concept of destruction also. There is a concept of
unmanifestation. God withdraws Himself and creation vanishes. Manifestion is
instantaneous, if the word can be used, because even time is a part of
manifestation only. Similarly unmanifestation is also instantaneous. It is like
a dream. How was the world in your dream created ? The dream world, including
its own timeline were created instantly. When you wake up, the world just
vanishes. Same is the case with this world too.
There are graphic and poetic descriptions about God
creating the world, maintaining it and then destroying it. These are only
figurative to explain the above concept. They should not be taken literally.
2.15.What does Hinduism say about
conversion ?
There is no concept of conversion in
Hinduism. Hinduism believes in one God. If you read the Bible, you can see
expressions like "God of the Egyptians", "God of Israelites", etc. Hinduism does
not believe in many Gods like this. Hinduism believes in one God, whom everyone
of every religion call by various names and worship in their own way. It is said
in the Vedas that "God is one. The wise men call Him by various names." You
should note here that the people who call God by various names are called "wise
men". In the Bhagavat Gita, it is said that in whatever way a man worships God,
God being Omniscient, knows that He is being worshipped and responds to the
sincerity of the worshipper. Hinduism accepts diversity of religions and accepts
the validity if several paths, and so there is no concept of conversion.
Hinduism cares only about vertical conversion. Hinduism
encourages and helps a Christian to be a better Christian and a Muslim to be a
better Muslim. Any Hindu saint will ask a Christian to have faith in Christ and
go to Church regularly. He will ask a Muslim to have faith in Allah and perform
the religious duties ordained in the Koran sincerely. Hinduism does not support
horizontal conversion from one faith to another.
Hindus consider claims that "if you do not believe in
Christ, you will be doomed" as a disparaging remark on Christ. Christ is a
personification of selflessness. His love is unconditional. Putting conditions
like this on Him is blasphemy.
2.16.What does Hinduism say about
science ?
Science and Hinduism do not contradict.
They complement each other. Science and technology cater to the meterial needs
of man. But man does not live by bread alone. The psychological, emotional and
spiritual needs of man are catered to by arts and religion. They have entirely
different domains of operation. So there is no way they can be compared. Both
are needed for a balanced life.
2.17.What is Hinduism's stand on
human cloning ?
Hinduism considers the cloned persons to be different from
each other. Hinduism sees the soul and not the body. Even if the body is cloned,
the soul is different. So from the religious point of view, there is absolutely
no difference between a normal human being and a cloned human being. Biological
issues like dangers of genetic disorders, etc are left to the biologists to
discuss.
2.18.What is Hinduism's stand on
euthanasia (assisted suicide) ?
According to the Doctrine of Karma, a person cannot escape
from his/her Karma by commiting suicide. Whatever has to be faced has to be
faced. If one tries to escape from a problem in this birth, it will have to be
faced in a higher proportion in a subsequent birth. Also, committing suicide
adds a big Karmic burden on the individual.
Coming to Euthanasia, assisting the suffering person by
giving moral and other form of support to bear with the difficulties and if
possible to alleviate the difficulties is the best thing that his/her well
wishers can do. Taking away the life is only postponing the problem. If the
suffering person is not a party in the decision, then it is a mere postponement
of the manifestation of the Karma for the suffering person. Whereas for the
people involved in making the decision, the mental attitude is what counts.
To summarize, in the best case, it does not help anyone in
any way.
2.19.What is Hinduism's stand on
abortion and contraception ?
Issues like pre-marital and extra-marital sex are social
issues. From the religious point of view, uncontrolled lust is harmful for the
spiritual development of the individual. Abortion and contraception for reasons
like family planning, to avoid an unhealthy child, etc are perfectly acceptable.
Even in case of unsocial conception, it is better to abort than to leave an
uncared for child who may grow up into an anti-social human being.
2.20.How do Hindus pray ? What is the
Hindu prayer ?
The sign of showing respect in India is to join both the
palms facing each other vertically. The level of the palms can be at heart,
throat, forehead or above the head. At the heart level, it shows an expression
of loving devotion. At the throat level, it shows an expression of a servant to
the Master. At the forehead level, it shows an expression of respect because of
the acknowledgement (by knowledge) of the greatness of God. At the level above
the head, it is an expression to tell "Lord, it is You who has become everything
in this world. There is nothing in this world but You."
The traditional prayer of the Hindus means this: "Oh Lord,
You are the Light of the world. Please enlighten my understanding. Let me see
everything in the right light." The prayer does not ask for anything else. This
prayer is called the Gayatri. The idea is that we learn from mistakes and
suffering in life. It is the hours of sorrow that remind us of God. So merely
asking for freedom from misery and suffering may actually stunt our growth. What
we need is strength to carry our load. Again, strength without understanding
will be more destructive than constructive. Right understanding of the choices
and experiences in life will enable us to take the right decisions, give us
strength to carry out our plans and the fortitude to face success and failure.
So the prayer asks only to "enlighten the understanding". Growth will follow
naturally.
In the Bhagavad Gita, the Lord says, "Whoever worships in
whatever form, by whatever name, by whatever means, worships Me alone. I am the
recepient of all worship. I respond to their worship and strengthen the faith of
people in the form and name they worship." Thus, what us needed is sincerity.
Form, words, rituals, etc dont really matter. God looks into our hearts. The
best prayer that one can offer to God is to tell Him from the heart "I love
You".
2.21.Do Hindus say any prayer before
eating food ?
Traditional Hindus tell a prayer before food. The prayer
means this: "The food is God. The plates, spoon, etc are God. The eater is God.
The fire of hunger is God. The act of eating is God." A peculiar prayer!! It
implies that I dont eat for my sake. I eat as an activity ordained by Nature.
The order of Nature is such that one organism lives at the cost of another. Life
to one being is death to another. It is impossible to maintain the life of this
body without taking the life of millions of germs, food grains, fruits, leaves,
seeds, plants, animals, etc. So the prayer before food implies that life is
being offered to life. It is not for mere enjoyment that you eat, but as a
necessary action to keep the body alive. This attitude is applicable to almost
all actions in life.
Back to Top
Intermediate Level Questions:
3.1. How is man reborn ? Why do bad
things happen to good people ?
According to the
doctrine of Karma, every situation we face in life is the result of our past
aspirations and actions. Actions are mere expressions of aspirations. Also, they
are reflective. To put it crudely, if you wish that a dog should get hit, then
it sows seed for you to become a dog and get hit. If you wish and do good to
others, you will see all good people around you helping you when you are in
need.
During the course of our life, we think and do so many
things. Every thought and action has to bear fruit. Some of our thoughts and
actions may be such that it is not possible for them to bear fruit in this life
itself. This necessitates a subsequent life.
Bad things happen even to people who think and do good in
life as the result of their thoughts and action in a previous life. So
calamities in life should not discourage a person to sever from the path of
virtue.
Now the question is, since we think and do things till the
last breath, how is it possible to get out of this cycle of birth and death. The
answer is that thoughts and actions are binding only when there is a sense of
doership. Actions done for the sake of action, without a sense of reward or
doership do not bind, and do not force personal effects.
3.2. What is the aim of life ?
The aim of life is to realize the freedom of the Self from
all limitations. In reality, the Subject - the real Self - is totally free from
the apparent bondage and limitations imposed by the mind. The concept of
individuality, world and their interaction are all in the mind only and do not
affect the real Subject. When the person realizes this, he is no longer subject
to sorrow and other psychological problems and inconveniences. His leads life in
a very natural and harmonious manner. The aim of life is to achieve this
freedom.
3.3. How do I determine
what is right and what is wrong ?
The aim of life
is spiritual freedom, which can be perceived in life as psychological freedom.
Anything which leads you to more psychological freedom is right. Anything which
leads to psychological bondage is wrong. The problem is that psychological
bondage creates aberration in perception, which leads to not being able to
clearly see which way leads to bondage and which way leads to freedom. In such
cases, you may need the guidance of social norms, words of saints and the law.
To start with, you should follow the right path as much as visible and possible.
As the result your psychological bondages will become weaker. Your vision will
become clearer. With this you will be able to make better decisions, which will
make the distinction still clearer.
You should also keep in mind that in most cases, right and
wrong are relative to the person involved and cannot be judged rightly from the
point of view of another person.
3.4. Which is the path better
for me - Karma, Bhakti, Jnana or Yoga ?
It depends
on your mental temperament. Everyone of us have the abilities to work, to love,
to analyze and to cencentrate. One might have more of something that the other.
The paths are not contradictory. They aid each other. So you need not worry too
much about which path to take. To start with, you can take an integrated
approach. Soon a natural shift will come to whatever you are more inclined to.
Still it is better to keep some of all the paths to be more balanced. This will
lead to better results.
3.5. Who is a Guru ? Is a human Guru
really needed ?
A Guru is one who can inspire and
instruct you towards God realization. In fact there is only one Guru, who is God
Himself. The human Guru is God Himself instructing the disciple. A very advanced
aspirant may not need the Guru in a human form. But, in general, a human Guru is
needed. The human mind always wants a live example to imitate and a live hero to
worship. The human Guru fulfils these psychological requirements and effectively
brings about God realization without much difficulty.
3.6. Can I have more than one Guru ?
How do I identify my Guru ?
You should have one
primary Guru, who is the one who has given you a mantra to chant or a spiritual
practice to follow. You can have other holy people who can give you
supplementary instructions, but these should never contradict the primary Guru's
words. The former is called Diksha Guru and the latter are called Shiksha Gurus.
As it is God himself who comes as all Gurus, you should never take lightly the
person who has told you explicitly that he is your Guru. If subsequently someone
else tells you that you have gone to a wrong Guru and asks you to completely
discard the words of the first Guru, ruthlessly discard the words of the second
person. Stick to the first Guru and pray to God to clear you off your confusion
and guide you. A real Guru always takes you higher based on the past path. He
never asks you to discard any faith you have followed before.
In most cases, you do not have to make a real search for
the Guru. You need to understand that the aim of life is God realization and try
to have the company of holy men and other aspirants as much as possible. In due
course of time, you will naturally develop a liking towards one holy person and
the person may become your primary Guru. Most of the holy men can quickly see
your temperament and tell you if they can be your Guru and if necessary suggest
another holy man as a possibility of being your Guru. What is needed is the zeal
towards God realization. The rest will follow at the right time. You need not be
too anxious about it.
3.7. How do I meet a saint ?
What are the formalities involved ? How should I approach him ?
A saint should be approached with reverence and an open mind.
Often you would have heard or read several things about the saint before you
meet him. Brush everything aside - both the good and bad remarks. Approach with
an open mind and reverence as a person who is devoted to the Goal. Most of the
saints do not expect any formalities. As a way to express your reverence, you
may take some offerings of fruits and flowers to the saint. This is not a barter
system or a business. It is just an expression of reverence and love. In most
cases, the saint will not give much importance to your offerings. The saint may
distribute your offerings to the people there, or keep it for distributing
later. Very rarely he may take these for his perusal. If he does so, it is a
great previlege to you.
3.8. What is Brahman ? What is my
relationship with Brahman ?
Brahman is the term
for God in Hinduism. Brahman is the core of your existence. Hinduism defines
Brahman as existence, consciousness and bliss - Sat-Chit-Ananda. Do you exist?
That existence is a property of the Brahman in you. Are you aware of your
existence? That awareness comes from the Brahman in you. Have you felt joy
anytime in your life due to any reason? That joy comes from the Brahman in you.
This is the definition of Brahman or God given by Hinduism. Brahman is infinite
and so perfect.
3.9. If Brahman is infinite,
where does the imperfection which we see come from ?
The imperfection is only in the mind. The imperfection is an
illusion. We are all perfect. We are in a state of hypnotism that we are not
perfect and so we behave imperfectly. It is like a person getting dressed like a
beggar to play the role of a beggar in a drama, but getting lost in himself and
thinks he is really and beggar and suffers because of that. Hinduism calls us
"Children of immortal bliss". We are the children of God and so rightful heirs
to his purity, peace and glory.
3.10. What are the defects in man ?
What is karma yoga ? How does it take man to perfection ?
Man operates in three basic realms. The gross, subtle and
causal. In the gross level, the physical body with its sense organs and organs
of action is the field of operation. In the subtle level, the mind with its
organs like intellect, memory and the faculty of emotion is the field of
operation. The causal level consists of the basic limitation, which makes a
person feel an individual existence in relation to the environment.
Defects in these three realms of operation manifest as
lust (desire for sensual pleasure and comfort), greed (desire for possessions
and human relationship) and ego (desire for fame) respectively. All other
defects like anger, jealousy and delusion result from these three basic defects.
These realms can be related to the three Gunas (qualities)
of man. Tamas is when the goal of a person is in the physical realm. Rajas is
when the goal of a person is in the mental realm. Sattva is when the goal of a
person is in the causal realm. When a person goes beyond the three types of
defects, he naturally goes beyond the three Gunas. The aim of human life is to
overcome these three types of defects, transcend the three Gunas, and thus
become perfect.
Karma Yoga defines three practices to free ourselves from
these three defects. They are Yagna (activity), Daana (charity) and Tapas
(austerity). Yagna helps us to move from Tamas to Rajas. Daana helps us to move
from Rajas to Sattva. Tapas helps us to transcend Sattva. Every person has a
mixture of all the three Gunas and so we should follow all the three practices.
The desire for physical pleasure is the vestigial remnant
of animal nature in us. This has to be countered by Yagna.
Yagna is activity. Whenever there is a choice
between action and inaction, we should choose to act. Action is different from
reaction. Reaction is blind retort against a change in the environment. Action
is a step taken not merely in reply to an environmental change but in view of
positive development. Reaction should be avoided. We should always be engaged in
some positive developmental activity. Activity is both physical and mental.
Activity will free us from desire for physical pleasure. Activity results in
wealth, which forms the basis of the next practice - Daana.
Daana is charity. The fruits of action should be
put back into the environment (society). Nature follows a strict causal law. We
will get what we deserve - nothing more, nothing less. But this is in the long
run. There can be apparent violations to this in the short term, which is often
misleading. If we take more than what we deserve, later we will have to part
with something close to our heart. So, the best course is to give back to Nature
anything more than what is barely necessary. This positive step to maintain the
balance will free us from unnecessary anxiety and trouble. Charity leads to
fame, which forms the basis of the next practice - Tapas.
Tapas is austerity. The doership of Yagna and Daana
should be renounced. There is an underlying oneness in Nature. We are all
instruments in the hands of God. It is God alone who has become everything and
it is God alone who acts through everyone. Man is absolutely powerless before
the Will of God. Man's capacity to help is very limited compared to the amount
of help needed in the world. It is God who creates the seeds of activity and
charity in the minds of men. We are all mere machines in the hands of the
Operator. This renunciation of doership takes us beyond the three Gunas, which
is the aim of human life.
Thus Karma Yoga takes us from wherever we are to the
highest goal.
3.11. Why should one realize God ?
Most of the Upanisads start with one or many of the three
questions:
- Can we have eternal life?
- What is that, knowing which, everything is known?
- Can we be free from misery?
These three are the fundamental questions of mankind anywhere
in the world in any age. The student starts with concepts like life, happiness
(or the lack of it - ie. misery) and knowledge, which are cannotations of the
limited mind. But, the answer to the questions can be found only beyond the
mind. That is where philosophy ends and religion starts. The questions are posed
by an enquiring mind under the auspices of philosophy, whereas the answers are
given by a person who has had an experience beyond the mind under the auspices
of religion. Note that this distinction is made only in Western culture. Indian
culture does not make any distinction between philosophy and religion. Both are
complementary and fulfil each other.
The question "Why" is always a more deeper one than "What"
or "How". Take any subject and put the question "Why" in any form, like "Why
does this happen?", "Why should I do this?", etc Apply the same question to the
answer. Repeat this again and again. Invariably you will land up with either
"Why should I exist?" or "Why should I be happy?" or "Why should I know?". Thus,
existence, happiness and knowledge are the three most fundamental quests and
urges of mankind.
- Urge to Exist
- Urge to Know
- Urge to Be happy
These three urges are incompletely, temporarily and most of the times illusorily
satisfied by the various pursuits and achievements of life. Thus, every activity
is an urge to fulfil one or more of these three. The solution given by religion
has its basis beyond the mind, and completely satisfies all the three urges. It
is important to note that only the basis of the solution is beyond the mind, but
it effect is in the mind too. Otherwise, we will be solving a wrong problem. All
our bondage is mental and is due to a state of dissatisfaction of these urges.
When the urges are satisfied fully, the mind is naturally free from all
bondages. This is called Mukti or Freedom.
Thus, whether we like it or not, whether we know it or
not, the aim of all pursuits and activites is towards Mukti or Freedom.
Now, let us go one more step ahead and put a final "Why?"
to this urge itself. "Why these urges?" The answer given by the Indian
scriptures is "Because that is the natural state." Our natural state is to have
the three urges fully satisfied. The mind is under a state of delusion that they
are not satisfied. The mind is under a hypnotic spell of dissatisfaction. The
urge is merely the eagerness to return back to the natural state. When the mind
gets dehypnotized, it gets back its natural state and that is Mukti. A
dehypnotized mind clearly reflects the true nature, which is called Self. The
Hindu scriptures describe the nature of the Self as Sat (Existence), Chit
(Consciousness) and Ananda (Happiness).
3.12. Why is there evil in the
world ? Why is the world far from being perfect ?
The problem is in our expectation that the world should be
free from evil and misery. Why should it be so? We assume that a world with a
mixture of good and evil is imperfect. This assumption arises from our tendency
to strive towards joy and avoid sorrow. We have taken the aim of our life to be
happiness. When this is our aim, naturally a world which has a mixture of joy
and sorrow, good and evil appears imperfect to us.
The aim of life is not happiness and not even virtue. Aim
of life is wisdom. Misery and evil make us work towards their alleviation. This
work gives us experience. We face joy and sorrow. We face success and failure.
We face hopes and disappointments. This makes us think. We start seeking a
general solution to this problem. Thus experience forms the foundation of our
philosophical contemplation. This struggle towards understanding the Truth
eventually leads to an intutive understanding. This wisdom is the aim of life.
Thus, without this mixture of good and evil in the world,
no one can attain the ultimate aim of life. Thus, if we consider wisdom as the
aim of life, we do not find this world imperfect. We find that the world has the
right setup for every individual to attain this aim of life. There cannot be a
more perfect world !!
Back to Top
Advanced Level Questions:
4.1. What is Brahman ? What is Maya
? What is the nature of this world ? What is Nirvikalpa Samadhi ?
Warning: The presentation below gives an entirely
different world view. Though I have tried to present it as clearly as possible,
it is prone to be misunderstood. The idea may be revolting to your current
understanding of the world. You are free to write to me to discuss the
presentation below. My email address is at the bottom of this page.
Let us take the sun. It emits light. Assume that it does
not emit light. It emits heat. Assume that heat is also not there. It has a
gravitational field. Assume that that is also not there. It has a mass. Assume
that mass is also not there. It has a form and occupies space. Assume that that
is also not there. What is left? We have removed everything by which the sun can
interact with our senses and various scientific instruments which basically
extend our senses. Still the sun is there in our minds. Assume that everyone
forgets about the sun. Now, in the words of Indian philosophy, we have removed
the form (sense interactions) and name (mental image) of the sun. In short, we
have removed all concepts of the sun. This does not mean that we have removed
the sun. There is two more factors which remain. One is called "limitation".
Still we distinguish the sun from other things. The other is called "existence".
The existence of an object is independant of its name, form and limitation. Now
let us remove the limitation. Now it is pure existence. Now there is no
difference between the sun and any other object. So at the existential plane,
there is only one that exists. There cannot be two. The concept of two comes
only by the introduction of a factor called limitation. This One is called
Brahman. The only attribute it has is that it exists. Thus we say that
everything is Brahman. As there is no limitation, we say it is infinite. This
gives us an idea of Brahman.
Now, let us see where do the other things come from. The
first thing to come is limitation. How does this arise? We say Brahman is aware
of itself. This creates a duality in the Whole. We cannot say why this arises.
This limitation aspect of Brahman is called Maya. Brahman does not change. As
Brahman has only existence as its attribute, the only way it can change is not
become non-existent, which contradicts itself. So Brahman cannot change. So what
is that which changes ? Nothing. So we say that the change is only an
appearance. Once we assume that duality has arisen, then we have to see how the
two parts interact. One part takes the role of the perciever and the other part
takes the role of the percieved. Just as a person creates worlds when he
day-dreams, the world with all its diversity is created. The mind arises as a
means to percieve. "Brahman sees itself as the world." says Yoga Vasishta. A
concept of "I am so and so." arises and we get entangled in what is percieved
and forget the true nature.
With this background, what is the nature of the world ? It
is only in the mind of the perciever. Who is the perciever ? "I" is the
perciever. It is just like a dream. Dream starts abruptly and ends abruptly. A
world is created in a moment where you are the daughter of so and so, born in
some city, aged a number of years, with a few faculties and skills, etc. You do
something in the dream and suddenly the dream ends abruptly, the dream world
vanishes and another dream starts. This world is similar. It comes into
perception suddenly, occupies the mind for a while and goes out of perception as
suddenly as it came. Birth, death, etc are all mere concepts. As every dream
world has its own timescale, every world has its own timescale. Just as one
cannot say how long a dream will be in the mind, no one can say how long this
world be in the mind. Just as you do not remember the incidents in one dream in
another, you do not remember the details of one world in another. The appearance
of a world in the mind is called birth and the disappearance of a world is
called death. Karma (fruits of thought, word and deed) and Samskara (tendencies
formed) are carried across. If you wish that you want to become a doctor, it
will create a Karma and to satisfy it, a world will appear in your mind where
you are a doctor. This happens just as a person who strongly desires to become a
doctor gets dreams in which he is a doctor.
There is no difference between the waking state and the
dream state. You see one world when you are awake. You "dream" into another
world. Then you "wake up" into another world. It is pre-filled memory which
makes you feel a continuity. Waking, sleeping, dreaming, etc are all concepts in
the mind. The "present" is the most real of all these conceptual worlds. Why are
the worlds created ? Because of Karma and Samskara. It is desire which creates
these worlds. If a person is desireless, then there is no reason why the worlds
should appear. There is no birth and no death. This is the state of Nirvikalpa
Samaadhi.
Even before that, when a person fully understands this and
is fully convinced, he sees the Brahman underlying this world. He is able to see
through the names, forms and limitation and is able to see the Reality. Though
the mind and the world have not vanished altogether, the person has seen the
Truth. This brings about a profound change in the attitude of the person. Slowly
desires die a natural death. There comes a time when they have totally died off
and the world vanishes for the last time. He reaches the state of Nirvikalpa
Samaadhi. What happens after that cannot be described.
Now what about the concepts of God, Guru, etc ? They all
hold good. It is like a person in your dream comes and tell you that you are
dreaming and asks you to wake up to the reality. There is no other way of a
dreaming person to know that he is dreaming. It is Grace that appears in the
form of scriptures, Guru, etc to indicate this to us. God is the name we give to
a person who knows the truth. The knower of truth knows himself as the Truth
itself. So the knower of truth is Truth itself. The various attributes we
ascribe to God helps us to slowly realize the Truth.
What about the various forms of God, lokas like Vaikunta,
etc ? They are all as real as this world. If you accept the world before your
eyes, you should accept all these also.
All this happens without any real change in Brahman. The
change is only an appearance. Why does this happen ? There can be no proper
answer to this. We may dismiss the question by saying, "It is all a game", "Just
to enjoy", "Just for fun", etc, but there are not real answers. The most
convincing answer (to me) is "It is natural to happen like this". We do not ask
"Why should the fire be hot?" It is similar to that.
Now the question is "What should a person do ?". Just
because the world is unreal, do we idle away ? The answer is "The world is as
unreal as your body and your hunger. If you can say "I will not eat because my
hunger is unreal." then he can idle. One has to do whatever is expected in the
situation he is in. But one should not get attached to the results or doership.
4.2. What is the relationship between
Maya and the Brahman ? Does Maya 'exist' ?
If you
accept the existence of mind, you cannot negate Maya. Mind is just another name
of Maya. What is Maya in the cosmic level is seen as mind in the individual
level. Brahman and Atman are names given to the same Reality at the cosmic and
individual level. The intermediaries are Maya and Mind. The illusive objects
percieved are the World (Jagat) and Personality (Jiva). Do not be to much
distracted by the terms. There is a heavy loss of terms here, especially because
we are using English. The same concept here will be named differently elsewhere.
Theoretically speaking, it is possible for Brahman to
exist without being aware of itself. All concepts and discussion about Brahman
are by the mind, which exists only when Brahman is aware of itself. So, there is
no way in which the mind can even get an inkling of a state when Brahman is not
aware of itself. So such a state is beyond description of the mind. So one
school of thought is to say Brahman cannot be without being aware of itself.
This is to say that Brahman and Maya cannot be separated. This is reflected in
the common paralance as "Without Sakti there is no Siva; without Siva there is
no Sakti." This is to say that Existence (Siva or Brahman) and Manifestation (Sakti
or Maya) cannot be separated. This is the only conclusion any mental process can
arrive at. So from this point of view, I agree that Manifestation is also an
attribute of Brahman. But the mind has the capacity of extrapolation. By
extrapolation, the mind can intellectually imagine a state where Manifestation
is not there. When you extrapolate thus, you are required to explain how
Manifestation arises. This again is not possible for the mind. It is like a
doctor being the gynaecologist to her grandmother during her mother's birth,
which is not logical. This has been explained with so many analogies. Sri
Ramakrishna says, "A salt doll went to measure the depth of the ocean, but
nothing was left to tell how deep the ocean was." He says this is what happens
when a person enters Nirvikalpa Samadhi. From all these, we can assume that such
Brahman can be there without Manifestation, but it cannot be described or
discussed by the mind.
4.3. What is the use of all this
theory ?
All this ultimately tells you three
things:
- The world is only a creation of the mind.
- And so is the individuality.
- Brahman alone is real, which appears as all these.
From this you need to draw a practical philosophy of living.
Otherwise it serves no purpose. This practical philosophy can be based on Jnana
or Bhakti, both are the same. Jnana culminates in Bhakti and Bhakti culminates
in Jnana.
Basically do all your duties, but be unattached. An easy
way to do this is to surrender to God. It is God who has become everything and
everything happens by his wish. So everything will be for your good in the long
run. Whereever the Lord places you, do whatever is expected of you and do not
worry about the results and do not be attached to the doership. Every work is
God's work. You are not indispensable. You only a medium through which God gets
work done. It is ultimately He doing the work. Take whatever results that come
as His prasad. Do not have preferences. If you are given a choice exercise it
intelligently, but if you are not given a choice, accept whatever you get.
Forget that you are interacting with the world. You are really interacting with
God in various forms and roles. Approaching the world with this attitude will
not bind you. Also do not take more than you need from the world. The world may
thrust wealth in your hand. It is really the Lord's wealth. It has been given to
you for proper disimbursement. Look upon yourself as a manager, while the wealth
really belongs to God. Put the Lord in the position of an Employer and do every
work as an offering to Him. Do not assume ownership of any possessions. Once you
start doing this, all the details of this path will fall in their place. The
path will become clear as you walk along it with the lantern of Faith in your
hands. There is nothing to be anxious about. You have the zeal. You add faith to
it. This chemistry will work wonders.
From the point of view of Jnana, we say everything happens
by coincidence. The concept of cause and effect is only in the mind. So it is
not proper to expect some results for our work. That does not mean we should be
idle. We should merely rise up to every situation we face. When everything is
coincidental, there is no concept of destiny or freewill. It is a state beyond
both. With this attitude to total detachment from the fruits of work and from
the sense of doership, live in the world naturally. Every occasion arises,
exists and subsides in your mind. There is nothing external. The real "I" is
both all inclusive and transcendent of all these. Be a mere witness.
Though both the paths sound different, essentially they
are the same. A bhakta says "everything is God". A jnani says "everything is I".
The bhakta says "everything happens by the will of God". The jnani says
"everything happens by mere coincidence". Both mean the same - "I am not the
doer".
There is a danger in accepting this state prematurely.
There are two stages to this. The first is surrender of fruits of action. The
second is surrender of doership. The second can be taken only after the first is
perfected. Otherwise it will be a mere escape route. First you have to learn to
accept whatever that comes, irrespective of your efforts. Not a thought of
dissatisfaction should arise in your mind. Only when this is achieved, you are
ready for the second stage. Till then, you have to take responsibility to your
actions.
What is the result of this? Peace of mind. Unalloyed joy.
Unshakable bliss. Nothing in the world can disturb you. Nothing can make you
sad. Ultimate and permanent freedom from all anxiety and sorrow. In one word -
"FREEDOM". This is called Jivanmukti. This is the goal of human life.
4.4. Is celibacy essential for
spiritual progress ?
As long as the mind dwells in
the plane of the body and sense pleasures, it cannot think of subtle things. Sex
is not a physical need of the body like food and water. It is a mere
psychological need and in fact a remnant of the animal qualities of man. Just as
the body has a few vestigial organs, sex is a vestigial faculty of the human
mind. When animals have only physical means of reproduction, man has higher
means. When a teacher teaches a student and passes on knowledge, the student
becomes partly a mental progeny of the teacher. When an artist draws a picture
which represents his thoughts, it becomes a means of his mental proliferation.
Every work of creativity leaves a mark about the person in the lives and minds
of generations to come. This is a unique way of reproduction endowed to man. An
animal physically attains immortality through its offsprings. A man attains
mental immortality through his deeds. Both these are imperfect means to
immortality. A still higher means is religion. By realizing the immortality of
the Self, real and absolute immortality is reached. Physical and mental means of
proliferation are crude approximations of this grand phenomenon of Self
realization.
By freeing the mind from the psychological bondage of sex,
the animal becomes a man. This is an essential step to Self realization. By
freeing the mind from the idea of sex, the mind becomes capabale of thinking at
a subtler plane. Self realization is the pinnacle of subtlity of the mind. So
celibacy is essential to spiritual life beyond a certain stage. In the early
stages, an aspirant may be able to get away with the mind still dwelling in sex,
but in course of time, he will hit a wall. The mind will not be able to proceed
further due to its inability to grasp subtler ideas. To cross that threshold,
celibacy is a necessity.
-
Why is Hinduism so confusing ?
There are multiple reasons for that. Trying to do an in
and out analysis without getting on to taste its fruit by practicing would
make one feel exhausted. Because it is not a religion of limited contours. It
is really an ocean of knowledge.
But don't we find quite contradicting statements in
Hindu scriptures ? What explains that contradiction ?
Science tells us that water becomes ice when its
temperature falls to zero degree centigrade or below. The same science also
tells that water can exist even in temperatures below zero degree in certain
conditions and the water is called super-cooled water. Which one to believe ?
The fact remains that both the statements are true however contradicting they
are. Hinduism - an open religion - supports the view that there could be
multiple facets of the same truth! And hence the things that have a value in
them would find their place in Hinduism. Some scriptures would say knowledge
is the way to the Supreme and some would say devotion is the way! There is no
need to be confused. Choose the way that is appropriate in your situation, but
do remember just because one is approprite for you, the others do not cease to
be true !!
-
Why there are so many gods in Hinduism ?
Generally Hindus believe in one Supreme God. But there are many devas who are
praised in the religion. These devas are actually the life supporting powers.
For example Sun, Moon, and Air without which the life cannot exist. God is
called devadeva because It is the Thing on which even all these celestial
powers survive on. In Hinduism these elements which make the life possible are
praised along with the Very Essential God. This gives the feeling that Hindus
believe in many gods.
-
Why Hindus worship idols ?
Though the Supreme God is beyond a definite form with specifiable attributes,
the Attributeless could be enjoyed only at a matured yogic state. For the
benefit of the creatures the God appears in various forms for the matured
visions. These splendid forms are easy to comprehend even for a layman. Apart
from these Hindus worship the holy symbols like shiva li.ngam those making
ease in meditation and worship at the same time referring to God's
formlessness. A carrier to move to the destination with ease.
-
Does Hinduism prohibit meat eating ?
There are actually very less things as prohibits, commands, mandates etc in
Hinduism. So in this case too Hinduism does not prohibit, but it recommends
that meat eating could be avoided for spiritual benefits and kindness towards
fellow creatures.
-
What is Hinduism's sacred text ?
Hinduism is not based on one single text book. Though it could be said that
vedas are the base, in essence veda is nothing but knowledge. It is the
science of the self and Supreme. The science can not be limited to one book so
is Hinduism.
-
What are the marks on the forehead of Hindus ?
There are many virtual lotuses of power locus in the human body. The one at
the place between the eye brows is highly powerful (which could be felt). This
highly sensitive point is protected with the kumkum or chandan dots. Shaivites
adorn their forehead with the Holy Ash the one with medicinal power and
spiritual meaning and the vaishnavas with the shri chUrNam and so on each
indicative of something.
-
Why is Hinduism so complex to understand ?
Well, Hinduism was not born out of the thoughts of one particular philosopher
or at one particular time. It is an accumulation of the knowledge and
experience of seers from ancient time. Also as it does not impose the
supremacy of one specific postulation hence many complementary at times
totally different concepts exist because of this openness. This advantage
makes it sophisticated.
-
So could it not be understood by simple minds ?
It could certainly be and it is. Apart from being sophisticated it is also
having various step by step procedures that arose out of the sophisticated
thesis, for the layman to follow.
-
Who can become a Hindu ? Can one be a Hindu only by
birth ?
No, not at all. As the knowledge in Hinduism is not in a closed boundary,
Hinduism does not limit itself to any closed boundary of land, language or
race. In fact people embracing Hinduism have been there for ages.
-
Hinduism is the religion of one particular land called
India, right ?
No, actually not. This new name called Hinduism given to this discipline is
what makes it appear it as the religion of one land. Though it is currently
practiced mainly in India there are references in scriptures like Shiva mahaa
puraaNam that this worship was spread throughout the world. While the other
parts have forgotten this history it is still in practice now in other parts.
-
The Aryans invaded the Dravidans and ...
No, No. The words aryan and dravidan seem to be misinterpreted. The word arya
has been used as a title of dignity while dravida refers to the land Deccan
and not a race. The wars that are said to have happened between these two
appears to be a tint of imagination added to the purANic, epical events.
-
What is this caste system ?
Quite long ago the society was divided into four castes depending upon the
nature of service they do so that they together make sure the smooth running
of the social system. It was like the operational divisions of organizations.
These four castes were the four functional pillars on which the society was
standing. In the course of time the caste started to get determined by birth
and later some of these sections started considering themselves superior to
others. This finally led to the cruelty and inhuman behaviors of
untouchability etc. There has been time and again cautions from Hindu scholars
against these inhuman behaviors. Now this system is getting phased out and the
Hindus should be soon out of the bad taste it left.
-
What is the status of women under Hinduism ?
Hinduism that views God as both masculine and feminine (and neuter too),
suggests the role of women hand in hand with her male counterpart. Feminity is
worshipped in the forms of rivers, land, etc. Females have the right to
perform worship as their male counterparts. There are many vedic sages,
philosophers of later day, poets queens and so on from the womenfolk (1). If
the male has the authority over the operations, the female commands the
respect of the family. They do not compete but complement to form a better
society. Quite naturally the wife is called saha dharmini or the
companion in the dharma. In the course of time and especially in the last
millenium there has been an major deterioration of this status due to whatever
circumstances. It is time to shun away all those dirt accumulated on the way
and rediscover the glory of the ancient equality.
-
Who can be a Hindu ?
All the people, without restrictions of any sort. For, the God is common to
the one living in Arctic, Antartic as well as in Sahara. It is the God of
those things beyond this Earth. Hinduism welcomes the pure knowledge from all
horizons as well as can provide the paths for the whole world, with no
exceptions, to lead a life that is relishable and that takes to the ever
lasting Eternal Bliss.
Here is a statement from the heart of the vedas
May the mind stabilize on the rudra, by which
we, the two legged creatures, four legged ones, the whole world prosper !
The Grace of God does not limit to even just human
beings. Its is for all the lives in this earth and beyond ! So Hinduism
emphasises that not only can all the humans worship through its path, but also
shatters away all barriers that differentiate even animals to be not eligible
for God's grace.
|
|
If a person has at least one Hindu parent or has chosen to adopt Hindu
principles, and celebrates Hindu festivals, one may be considered a Hindu.
There are many views in this
regard.
One way of looking at it would suggest that a Hindu would observe at least
some Hindu traditions as being part of a community. For example:
- in lifecycle events like marriage ceremonies, death
ceremonies etc;
- in annual and seasonal festivals like Navraatri (or
Dusherra), Diwaali (or Deepaavali), Krishna Janmaasthami, etc;
- general community practices, like temple worship,
etc.
Some higher levels of criteria may include such
characteristics as having worthwhile objectives (Purushaartha) in life (see
question 6, principle iii), believing in rebirth and evolution of the soul,
and working towards ultimate realization.
From a strict traditional sense, to be a Hindu, one must either accept the
Vedas & Vedaangas and/or Aagama & Tantra.
Top of Page
As long as one is praying at home, it is not necessary
to go to a temple to remain a Hindu. One never stops being a Hindu.
While prayer at home is good, prayer at a temple is much better, because the
temple is a specially consecrated place, and the idols are specially
consecrated idols. The atmosphere and spiritual ambiance in a temple are
more powerful and effective. Just as we do watch video pictures at home but,
even so, go out occasionally to a theatre to see a film, we can pray daily
at home, but need to visit a temple as often as we can.
While there is no one single practice required
for a Hindu, a Hindu would be expected to follow at least one of the many
Hindu practices. Since temple worship is only one such practice, others may
be substituted. And one never stops being a Hindu unless one chooses to
relinquish Hinduism by actively converting to a non-Hindu faith.
However, there is a special importance for temple worship in modern living,
particularly outside India. Since the temple is a consecrated place, the
effectiveness of any practice in the temple is likely to be more powerful.
The energy of this consecration is described often by temple visitors as a
feeling of peace, bliss, happiness, etc. This, combined with the opportunity
to interact with Hindu culture (which may not be available in ones
neighborhood), becomes a double incentive for Hindus outside India to visit
a temple regularly.
Top of Page
There is no traditional Hindu practice to
convert others. However, historically Hinduism has spread to Southeast Asian
countries like Cambodia and Indonesia in earlier centuries. Therefore, it
would be reasonable to conclude that Hinduism does not actively seek to
convert others, but there is room for anyone who wishes to become a Hindu.
There is no conversion ceremony prescribed in
the ancient tradition, although some modern leaders have invented some.
Since anybody can claim to be a Hindu by adopting the principles and
practices, there is no prescription in the sacred texts to proselytize
others into the faith. Therefore, it would be reasonable to conclude that
Hinduism does not actively seek to convert others, but there is room for
anyone who wishes to become a Hindu. An observation made by some scholars
suggests that by a proper study of Hinduism, a Hindu would become a better
Hindu, a Muslim a better Muslim, a Christian a better Christian, a Jew a
better Jew, and anyone a better human being.
Top of Page
The four stages of life
recognized in Hinduism are:
i) Life as a student - Brahmacharya
ii) Householder - Grihasta
iii) Reclusive and meditative seeker away from crowd - Vaanaprasta
iv) Renunciate (seeking Moksha) – Sanyaasa
[Please review worthwhile objectives of life in Question 6, 3rd principle of
Hinduism]
Top of Page
Karma is the result of thoughts, words and deeds
that stay with us birth after birth until we live out their consequences –
as you sow, so you reap. The law of Karma can be considered as a universal
law of cause and effect.
Karma refers to both “act” (or action) as well
as “results of thought, word and deed.” In the context of rebirth, Karma
refers to the latter – the idea of cause and effect. Any thought, word or
deed, that is not performed dispassionately with no interest in the results,
yields Karma. Well-intentioned acts yield positive Karma (or Punya) and
ill-intentioned acts yield negative Karma (Paapa). Such consequences have to
be lived out.
Top of Page
Following are core beliefs/principles of Hinduism:
- Law of Karma and
Reincarnation – Each one of us is more than the body. Our true self
does not die with the body. Based on how we live our life, we are born and
reborn taking different life forms until we evolve to the point of no
birth, where we become one with God or stay close with God. (See question
5 for more details on Karma.)
- Freedom of Practice –
One can be a Hindu by being a good person and following any type of
worship practice that one finds appealing.
- Worthwhile Objectives of
Life – Hinduism accepts that through life one can do many great things
before one ultimately reaches God. Studying well, earning well, getting
married, having children, being a good citizen and doing service to
society, and then going beyond all of these and living life as a detached
person ready to reach God, are all part of Hindu living and the path
towards God.
- Divine Manifestation –
Most Hindus believe that from time to time God will manifest on earth to
help us keep to the right path and make us better. Raama and Krishna are
examples of such forms of God coming to earth in human form.
The following are considered core beliefs/principles of
Hinduism:
- Law of Karma and
Reincarnation – That the body is only the carrier of the
consciousness, which in turn is the carrier of the soul is a fundamental
assumption of Hinduism. This requires the consciousness to undergo birth
after birth in different bodies, carrying with it the “Karma” of previous
existence, until the consciousness evolves to the point of melting away
with only the pure soulful awareness remaining.
- Freedom of Path with the
Ultimate Goal of Realization – Individuals may choose whatever path is
natural to them. All paths are ultimately supposed to lead to soulful
awareness (living life as an observer) culminating in salvation. The four
paths generally recognized as broad categories that encompass all paths
are the paths of seeking knowledge (Jnyaana Yoga), doing self-less service
(Karma Yoga), practicing physical and mental exercises (Raaja/Dhyaana
Yoga) and the practice of devotion (Bhakti Yoga). Within these four, one
can conceivably fit every activity that one performs in a day – the
attitude towards the activity making all the difference. For those
interested, the specific place of each practice differs in different
philosophies of Hinduism.
For example:
A. In SAANKHYA-YOGA
Lowest Path is KARMA Yoga
Then BHAKTI
Then JNYAANA
Highest is DHYAANA/RAAJA Yoga
B. In MIIMAAMSAA
Lowest Path is DHYAANA/RAAJA Yoga
Then BHAKTI
Then JNYAANA
Highest is KARMA Yoga
C. In SHANKARA-VEDAANTA
Lowest is KARMA
Then BHAKTI
Then DHYAANA
Then JNYAANA
D. In RAAMAANUJA-VEDAANTA
Lowest Path is KARMA Yoga
Then JNYAANA
Then DHYAANA
Then BHAKTI
Then PRAPATTI
[Prapatti or Sharanaagati, although a new term here deserves special
mention. It is specific to Raamaanuja Vedaanta and can be considered the
highest level of Bhakti. It is complete unconditional surrender to the
will of God. One flings oneself at the mercy (Dayaa) of the Deity and
hopes for the gift of Moksha. Raamaanuja bases this doctrine on
Shvetaashvatara Upanishad VI:18, Vaalmiki Raamaayana Yuddhakaanda 18:33
and Bhagavad Gita XVIII:66.]
E. In MADHVA-VEDAANTA
Lowest is KARMA Yoga
Then DHYAANA
Then JNYAANA
Then BHAKTI
In the path of devotion (BHAKTI), people have choice with respect to their
worship practices as well as view of the divinity. God can be worshipped
as formless (Unmanifest Brahman) or in any form (Roopa of deities)
including idols, icons, statues, pictures (Bimbhas), Saligram (fossilized
shell), Linga etc. in the firm belief God will present Himself in the form
the devotee desires.
- Worthwhile Objectives of
Living – Hinduism considers living with good conduct (Dharma),
acquisition of wealth (Artha), enjoyment of love and pleasure (Kaama), and
salvation (Moksha) as worthwhile objectives of living.
One can glean a hierarchy in these objectives coinciding with the 4 stages
(Aashramas) of life recognized in Hinduism and the 4 sections of the Vedas
as follows:
ARTHA = BRAHMACHAARYA = MANTRA (or Samhita)
KAAMA = GRIHASTHA = BRAAHMANA
DHARMA = VAANAPRASTHAA = ARANYAKA
MOKSHA = SANNYAASA = UPANISHAD
- Avataar or Divine
Incarnation – Vedaanta school of Hinduism, the most popular school of
these times, accepts the idea that the Divinity can be born in a body from
time to time to show the path and liberate others. The ten Avataars are
well known, and among them the story of Raama in Raamayana and of Krishna
in Mahaabhaaratha are even better known. An Avataar is a step taken by God
out of His free will, but a human being’s rebirth is due to prior karma.
The other schools of Hinduism ignore the entire aspect of Avataars. Even
among the Vedaanta schools of Hinduism there are some differences towards
the view of the Avataar, but they all accept the idea, unlike the other
schools.
- Variety in the View of
Divinity – Hinduism accommodates the idea of a single God and no God
with the ambiguity of multiple gods (polytheism). The view of it depends
on the school of Hindu philosophy. (See question 7 for more details on
schools of Hinduism)
Vedaantic & Nyaaya-Vaisheshika View: There is one God or Divine
Power that is part of everything that we see and beyond. Beings can be
within bodies or exist in pure spirit (consciousness) form, and are all
part of or within the control of the Ultimate.
Yoga-Saankhya and Mimaamsa Views: While non-theistic, they accept
the existence of gods (Devas) – more appropriately thought of as spiritual
beings with a portfolio in the governance of cause and effect in the
universe – but reject the idea of one Supreme Being. The Samhita (Mantra)
and Braahmana segments of the Vedas mention no Supreme Being, but praise
many such spiritual beings, even though the Upanishads do speak of one
Ultimate Divinity (Para-Brahman).
- Damnation or What? –
The Vedas speak of no damnation. In general, there is no idea of damnation
in Hinduism, other than being dammed to be reborn until all Karmas are
wiped out.
Dvaita-Vedaanta of Madhva is the lone dissenter among the Hindu systems
in this regard. It does believe that certain souls go toward everlasting
damnation. This doctrine of theirs is based on their interpretation of
Bhagavad Gita (Ch XVI:20).
Top of Page
Nyaaya-Vaisheshika, Yoga-Saankhya, Mimaamsa and Vedaanta are the recognized
schools of Hinduism. Within Vedaanta there are three major schools: Advaita
Vedaanta of Shankaraacharya, Vishishta-advaita Vedaanta of Raamanujaacharya,
Dvaita-Vedaanta of Madhvaachaarya. Within Mimaamsa, there are two schools of
Prabhaakara and Kumaarila respectively. All schools of Hinduism accept the
Vedas as the Ultimate Truth. Vedas and other holy texts are terse and hard
to understand. So great sages and teachers of the past have interpreted the
Vedas and other holy texts differently. Therefore there are many schools.
While it is important to understand these schools to understand the
different Hindu traditions, one can be a good Hindu without learning the
details of these schools.
Although most Hindus today
have grown up in the Vedaantic school traditions, contemporary Hinduism
recognizes the historical development of 7 schools of Hinduism, which
started as 6 schools before Shankaraacharya.
The seven schools that formed between 400 CE and 1300 CE are:
A. Nyaaya-Vaisheshika
B. Saankhya-Yoga
C. Prabhaakara Mimaamsaa
D. Kumaarila Mimaamsaa
E. Shankara Vedaanta (Advaita)
F. Raamaanuja Vedaanta (Vishistha-advaita)
G. Madhva Vedaanta (Dvaita)
[It must be noted that while the three major schools of Vedaanta are
recognized here, there are other minor schools as well with small
following.]
Previous to that between 100 CE and 400 CE, the six schools were Nyaaya,
Vaisheshika, Saankhya, Yoga, Mimaamsaa and Vedaanta. Later some of these
paired off, while others developed different branches.
Essentially, a philosophy would be called a Hindu philosophy if they
accepted the Vedas as the Ultimate Truth.
Even though all these schools accept the Vedas as the Ultimate Truth, there
is a difference in their approach. For instance, any school will be called a
school of Vedaanta only if the founder/s wrote a commentary on the
Upanishads, Brahmasutras and the Bhagavad Gita (all three together called
Prasthana-Trayi) to establish their point of view – the basis of
differentiation and establishment of a separate school of Vedaanta. The
other schools don’t require these commentaries. Mimaamsa schools give
importance only to the Samhita and Braahmana sections of the Vedas and are
focussed on rituals. Nyaaya-Vaisheshika emphasizes reasoning to understand
God. Yoga-Saankhya schools emphasize direct experience through meditation.
Each school has its view of the place of knowledge (or personal evidence) in
understanding God, the nature of reality, the idea of God, the nature of the
universe, the nature of souls, and the idea of Moksha or salvation.
Accordingly, each school has its preferred spiritual approach. The table at
the end of this answer provides clear distinction based on these academic
analysis criteria: Epistemology, Ontology, Theology, Cosmology, Psychology
and Soteriology.
For the ease of the general reader, the following comments are noted with
special emphasis on the Vedaanta schools which most Hindus follow:
- Nyaaya and Vaisheshika believes in one Supreme God
and considers reasoning (knowledge or Jnyaana) as the way of knowing God.
- Yoga and Saankhya does not accept the idea of a
Supreme God. In fact, this school alone accepts Vedas, not by faith like
the other schools, but as the verifiable truth. The focus of this school
is on direct experience.
- & D. The Mimaamsa schools, like the Saankhya-Yoga
philosophy, do not accept the idea of a Supreme God. They do, however,
accept that there are exalted and powerful, limited beings without gross
bodies like ours. These beings can help to deliver well-being in the
temporal world and the after cycles of birth and death, and salvation as
well. It is debatable whether these exalted beings should be referred to
as gods (indicating polytheism) or spirits. Mimaamsa philosophy considers
the practice of various rituals (karmas) as very essential. They believe
that the karmas (rituals) themselves yield the results, and there is no
Supreme God or Ishvara dispensing the results.
- Shankara Vedaanta, also called Advaita or
Non-dualism thinks of the Supreme God as Para-Brahman and even in Bhakti
mode feel free to visualize this Ultimate as any Ishtha Devata (favorite
deity). The philosophy is that each one of us is the Ultimate God, but yet
unrealized. It is Maayaa or illusion that makes one feel distinct from
others. All is one – there is no two: is the Advaita philosophy. In South
India, Advaitins are sometimes referred to as Smaartaas or non-Vaishnavas
or Ayyars (sometimes written as Iyers, which is a Tamil
| |